The hilarious detail came out recently on an episode of Bravo’s Watch What Happens Live, where Cooper and Cohen discuss that fateful first call with special guest Kelly Ripa.
“We had a phone call to talk before we actually went out on a date… and both of us decided, based on that phone call, ‘we’re not going to go on a date,’” Cooper laughed.
Of course the one detail the pair left out of the story was what brought them to that conclusion so quickly. Perhaps it has something to do with the last revaluation Cooper dumped on Ripa when the three appeared on WWHL together back in July, that he was “surprised” to learn Andy was a top?
Watch the video of the reveal below.